|
Friends of Wabakimi Response to the Proposed Bill 5: Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act.
Recently, the Friends of Wabakimi (FOW) became aware of the Ontario Government’s newly tabled omnibus bill, Bill 5: the Protect Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act. This bill undermines environmental protections to fast-track development, putting sensitive ecosystems, species at risk, critical habitat, and Indigenous rights at risk. This bill proposes to repeal the Endangered Species Act (2007), replacing it with a watered-down Species Conservation Act. Additionally, the new Special Economic Zones Act proposed would give Cabinet the power to exempt certain projects from provincial or municipal regulations. There are many notable and incredibly concerning changes within Bill 5. The definition for “habitat” of species at risk would be narrowed to only dwelling areas, such as nests and dens, and the areas surrounding them. This excludes critical areas for feeding, mating, and migrating from protection. For species such as the threatened Boreal Caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) which require large contiguous areas, this new definition would only cover a tiny fraction of their critical habitat. Projects previously requiring permits, if their activities were to threaten a species at risk, would now simply be required to register. These changes may also undermine Indigenous communities’ right to free, prior, and informed consent for projects taking place on their territories. As advocates for the preservation and protection of the diverse ecological, cultural, and historical resources of the Wabakimi Area, FOW is deeply concerned that Bill 5 may severely impact species at risk and critical environments in Ontario and the Wabakimi Area. In addition, commercial tourism may be negatively impacted by the potential increase in forest degradation for industrial use, given the large number of travellers both Canadian and international who visit the boreal forest for recreational purposes. The commenting period for Bill 5 will be open on the Environmental Registry of Ontario until May 17, 2025. You can submit your comments here. Below are further learning resources and actions, including a general text outline you may use in the ERO comment section. We encourage you to use all tools available. Sincerely, Friends of Wabakimi Board of Directors Additional Resources:
PDF Version of FOW Response
0 Comments
This report challenges the official government account issued by Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) each year of how forests in Canada are faring--The State of Canada’s Forests Annual Report. Drawing upon scientific evidence, data, and metrics, this report deconstructs the government’s overly positive portrayal of the Canadian forestry sector.
It introduces the basic factors Canada omits from these annual reports to arrive at its self-congratulatory conclusions, presenting evidence that the actual state of the forests is far more complex and worrisome, and the logging industry far less sustainable, than the government claims. Read the Report here! Policy Recommendations Transparent. Comprehensive. Balanced.
From THE NARWHAL:
New mineral claims within Grass River Provincial Park raise questions about the impacts of the race to mine ‘the building blocks for the green and digital economy’ on threatened species. Manitoba’s efforts to champion its critical mineral sector may be putting one of the province’s most iconic species at risk. During the Prospectors and Developers Association of Canada conference in Toronto earlier this month, Manitoba doubled down on its critical mineral commitments as it revealed the latest round of funding distributed under the Manitoba Mineral Development Fund. Critical minerals have been dubbed by the federal government to be the “the building blocks for the green and digital economy.” Among the $3.3 million in mineral development funds announced was a $300,000 grant to nickel mining company NiCan Limited to support “ongoing drill exploration” inside Grass River Provincial Park in northern Manitoba — a park the government describes as “a place where woodland caribou thrive, and where wolves, moose, bear and wolverine roam the lush forests.” But according to environmental group The Wilderness Committee, NiCan’s mineral claims don’t just fall within park boundaries — they also overlap the calving, rutting and summering grounds for a herd of threatened boreal woodland caribou. FULL ARTICLE HERE! Cutting the heck' out of Canada's boreal forest has put caribou at risk (latest from CBC news)1/21/2024 FULL STORY HERE
Canada is home to the largest boreal forest in the world, a vast expanse of wilderness rich in biodiversity that stretches from coast to coast. But a major new study examining nearly a half century of logging in Ontario and Quebec warns that clear-cutting has left forests in the provinces severely depleted — and puts woodland caribou at risk. The peer-reviewed research, published in the academic journal Land, found that logging practices between 1976 and 2020 have resulted in the loss of more than 14 million hectares of forest, an area roughly twice the size of New Brunswick. There are only 21 million hectares of older forest (defined as forests 100 years or older) remaining in the region. "We have been cutting the heck out of the boreal forest," said Jay Malcolm, a professor emeritus of forestry at the University of Toronto, and one of the authors of the study, conducted by researchers in Canada and Australia. The researchers calculated that older forests make up only 42 per cent of the forest area, and most of the remaining older forest is in the remote north. "It's very frightening. It was startling to see how little is left and how badly fragmented it is," said Malcolm. Read the rest here. New study suggests federal government underreports greenhouse gases from forestry sector. (CBC News · Posted: Jan 16, 2024 (Full story here.)
Canada's forestry sector is responsible for far more greenhouse gas emissions than show up in official tallies, potentially leading to policies that aren't in line with the country's climate goals, a new study suggests. The peer-reviewed study, published in the academic journal Frontiers in Forests and Global Change, found that annual greenhouse gas emissions attributable to forestry between 2005 and 2021 were, on average, nearly 91 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent — which would put the sector on par with emissions from the agricultural sector. (This was a joint study by scientists David Bysouth, Julee Boan, Jay R. Malcolm and Anthony R. Taylor.) By contrast, Canada's official inventory report shows the forestry sector acting as a carbon sink, which means it absorbs more carbon from the air than it sends into the atmosphere. The report has the sector absorbing an average of five million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent annually over the same period. Halifax Examiner Today: "Canadian Governments Fail to Count Environmental Costs of Industrial Logging" ----New report from eight leading North American and Canadian environmental organizations. A new report, The State of the Forest in Canada: Seeing Through The Spin, from eight leading North American environmental groups shows that the federal government is failing to tally the environmental and climate damage caused by industrial logging in Canada. ....the report “shows that Natural Resources Canada (NRCan)’s annual report downplays or ignores the significant impacts of industrial logging on biodiversity, the climate, forest integrity, and ecosystem services, and its potential infringements of Indigenous rights.” The report accuses Natural Resources Canada of failing “to provide Canadians with a transparent and credible synopsis” of basic information about the state of the nation’s forests, and of using “highly selective statistics and distorting or excluding essential information.” New study finds more than 14 million hectares cut in Ontario and Quebec since 1976New study finds more than 14 million hectares cut in Ontario and Quebec since 1976
Link to full story here! Canada is home to the largest boreal forest in the world, a vast expanse of wilderness rich in biodiversity that stretches from coast to coast. But a major new study examining nearly a half century of logging in Ontario and Quebec warns that clear-cutting has left forests in the provinces severely depleted — and puts woodland caribou at risk. The peer-reviewed research, published in the academic journal Land, found that logging practices between 1976 and 2020 have resulted in the loss of more than 14 million hectares of forest, an area roughly twice the size of New Brunswick. There are only 21 million hectares of older forest (defined as forests 100 years or older) remaining in the region. Link to full story here! A study finds that logging has inflicted severe damage to the vast boreal forests in Ontario and Quebec, two of the countryʼs main commercial logging regions. By Ian Austen and Vjosa Isai Ian Austen reported from Ottawa, and Vjosa Isai from Toronto. Canada has long promoted itself globally as a model for protecting one of the country’s most vital natural resources: the world’s largest swath of boreal forest, which is crucial to fighting climate change. But a new study using nearly half a century of data from the provinces of Ontario and Quebec — two of the country’s main commercial logging regions — reveals that harvesting trees has inflicted severe damage on the boreal forest that will be difficult to reverse. Researchers led by a group from Griffith University in Australia found that since 1976 logging in the two provinces has caused the removal of 35.4 million acres of boreal forest, an area roughly the size of New York State. While nearly 56 million acres of well-established trees at least a century old remain in the region, logging has shattered this forest, leaving behind a patchwork of isolated stands of trees that has created a landscape less able to support wildlife, according to the study. And it has made the land more susceptible to wildfire, scientists say. Read the full article here! "As part of the study, Professor Mackey and other researchers looked at the effects of logging on large groups of woodland caribou — animals that require large areas of older forest and that are affected by human disturbance. Logging roads, for example, make it easier for predators to hunt caribou, researchers said. Of the 21 herds within the two provinces’ boreal regions that researchers studied, 19 were at a high or very high risk of becoming unable to support their population." Leading ENGOs call on Canada to address forest degradation & Defining Forest Degradation in Canada12/14/2023 Biodiversity and climate crises deeply entwined (SEE ENTIRE ARTICLE HERE)
[Also Defining Forest Degradation in Canada - Article Here) Reposted from the David Suzuki Foundation: Canada cannot deliver on its global commitments to halt and reverse land degradation by 2030 unless it first accurately defines forest degradation, a coalition of leading environmental organizations working in Canada says. Today seven organizations released a science-based definition to spur urgently needed action. Canada’s commitment to halt and reverse the degradation of forest ecosystems by 2030 is an important part of the global effort to address the biodiversity and climate crises. However, while forest degradation is a scientifically grounded and internationally recognized issue, Canada has yet to articulate a credible framework to identify and eliminate the degradation that continues to occur not only in what remains of primary, old-growth and other high-integrity forests, but also within the wider managed forest. At present, Canada tracks rates of deforestation — the conversion of natural forests to another use — but does not track domestic forest degradation, of which industrial logging practices are a leading cause. As scientists have articulated, when a forest is degraded, its ability to provide critical ecosystem services such as climate mitigation, wildlife habitat and water filtration, diminishes. There is clear evidence that industrial logging degrades forests in Canada. For example, boreal woodland caribou, which require large expanses of mature and interconnected intact forests to survive, are currently threatened with extinction across the country due, primarily, to a legacy of disturbance from industrial activities including logging. Logging has so significantly degraded old-growth forests in British Columbia that the spotted owls that used to live there are now considered functionally extinct. See rest of the article here!
Originally published in the newsletter of the Thunder Bay Field Naturalists: Nature Northwest February 2023, Vol 77(1):15-19. Its about time the under-appreciated black spruce (Picea mariana) receives the attention and recognition it deserves. It’s resilience, economic importance and pan-Canadian distribution make it the stalwart, humble and inspirational icon of the Canadian boreal forest. Let’s celebrate its’ many contributions to Canadian life and psyche. Forget the geographically limited sugar maple and picturesque wind-swept white pine and let us respect black spruce as the most important and consequential Canadian forest tree. The black spruce is resilient and has robust, diverse and effective survival strategies. It reflects the legendary Canadian resilience demonstrated by indigenous peoples and early immigrants to cope with harsh and varied environmental conditions and a raw and rugged physical landscape. See Full Article here too, with more photos. (Thanks to Gerry for permission to reprint this article.) " ...the black spruce is an iconic Canadian tree species and deserves to be recognized as such. It should be our National Tree." |
AuthorJoin the Conversation and be part of Process Archives
May 2025
Categories |